Canadians are driving far less during COVID-19, which means fewer accidents. So why aren’t insurance companies offering across-the-board relief?
Insurers’ Excessive Profits Are a Symptom of Broken Regime
This ‘cardinal sin’ will increase your client’s auto insurance bill
Financial help lacking as COVID-19 shuts courts and kills legal work, lawyers say
COVID-19 & THE PRACTICE OF LAW
List of rules potentially affected by reforms to civil justice system
Opinion: How changes forced by pandemic are reducing litigation costs
Lawsuits and claims for accident benefits
Why it might get easier for plaintiffs to fund their lawsuits
Tribunal Watch Ontario – Statement of Concern
A Survey of Access to Rehabilitation Insurance Coverage for Adults with Brain Injury Caused by Motor Vehicle Collision
ODSP payouts should match CERB, say advocates
ODSP recipients struggling to survive pandemic
Additional ODSP help available during pandemic
 The defendants David Bush and MacDonald’s Propane settled with the plaintiffs during the course of the first trial. The active defendants since then have been the Corporation of the County of Lennox and Addington and the Corporation of the Town of Greater Napanee (the “Municipal Defendants”). These parties are represented by the same counsel.
 On the first appeal, the Court of Appeal held that the plaintiffs had established a reasonable apprehension of basis on the part of the trial judge. The appeal was allowed, and the matter remitted for a new trial. The Court of Appeal ordered “that each party should be responsible for their own costs at trial”: Lloyds v. Bush, 2012 ONCA 349, at para. 70.
 The second trial was heard in 2014, with reasons for decision released on 6 February 2015 (reported at 2015 ONSC 761; supplementary reasons at 2015 ONSC 5340). The Municipal Defendants were held 60% responsible for the plaintiffs’ damages; David Bush and 818601 Ontario Inc., c.o.b. as MacDonald’s Propane were held 30% liable; Leslie Lloyd was found to be 10% contributorily negligent.
a. General damages for Leslie Lloyd – $300,000;
b. Family Law Act damages for Jason Lloyd – $130,000;
c. Future care – $408,866;
d. Future attendant care – $2,000,000;
e. Future income loss – $1,260,000; and
f. Past income loss – $50,292.50.
 The second appeal decision, reported at 2017 ONCA 252, upheld the assessment of damages at the second trial, but ordered a new trial on the issue of liability (and the related issues of causation and contributory negligence). Costs of the second trial were remitted for determination at the third trial.
 The third trial was heard in April and May 2019, with reasons for decision released on 6 February 2020 and reported at 2020 ONSC 842. Liability was apportioned as follows:
a. Municipal Defendants – 50%;
b. David Bush and MacDonald’s Propane – 33%;
c. Leslie Lloyd – 17%.