• FAIR – supporting auto accident victims through advocacy and education
  • FAIR – supporting auto accident victims through advocacy and education
  • FAIR – supporting auto accident victims through advocacy and education

Latest News Articles

FAIR does not accept responsibility for comments, opinions, statistical information etc. associated with the links listed below. Any opinions, points of view, etc. are not necessarily shared by FAIR.

For a complete list of recent articles, please go to our 'Media Articles' page under 'In the News'.
We are updating our site and we appreciate your patience.

Plaintiff Facebook Photos Help Undermine Personal Injury Claim

Reasons for judgement were released this week by the BC Supreme Court, Vancouver Registry, largely rejecting claimed damages in a personal injury lawsuit due in part to concerns with the Plaintiff’s credibility and further due to Facebook photos entered as evidence at trial.

http://www.ilstv.com/plaintiff-facebook-photos-help-undermine-personal-injury-claim/

Tina Adams shows off ‘warrior wounds’ 1 year after car crash

Adams, then a student at John Abbott’s police technology program, was out on her routine jog with a friend June 12, 2015 when she was hit by a car, driven by an alleged drunk driver.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/tina-adams-hudson-car-crash-photos-1.3634158

Arteaga v Poirier, 2016 ONSC 3712 (CanLII)

[52]           Dr. Erin Boynton is an orthopedic surgeon who testified on behalf of the defence.  She was of the opinion that Ms. Arteaga’s injuries were minor.  She testified that Ms. Arteaga’s neck and shoulder pain complaints would be potentially reversible with the appropriate gentle exercise to improve her posture and core muscle strength.  She testified that there was no evidence of impairment of a significant orthopedic function that had been continuous since the date of loss.  She attributed Ms. Arteaga’s current pain complaints to abnormal posture and deconditioning, which were potentially reversible with exercise.  It was Dr. Boynton’s opinion while Ms. Arteaga had pain in her neck and left shoulder, this had nothing to do with the motor vehicle accident, but was related to the way that Ms. Arteaga carried her head.  There were no problems with the way that Ms. Arteaga carried her head or with her posture or with her muscle conditioning before this motor vehicle accident.  Nevertheless, Dr. Boynton was of the opinion that Ms. Arteaga’s pain was not caused as a result of trauma.  She disagreed with the opinions of Dr. Alpert and Dr. Jacobs that Ms. Arteaga did suffer from an inflammation of her nerves and chronic pain. Dr. Boynton believed that Ms. Arteaga suffered muscular pain after the accident but this was temporary because there was no serious injury.

Khanehshir and Certas 2016-06-06, Arbitration, Final Decision, FSCO 4920

 https://www5.fsco.gov.on.ca/AD/4920

Dr. Tuff indicated that the medical brief provided to him was small. The documents of particular significance to him, and reviewed by him in the report, were the disability certificate (OCF-3), dated December 12, 2014, by Dr. Luela Louis referred to above and the treatment and assessment plan (OCF-18) of Dr. Keeling, dated February 25, 2015. The other documents listed in the appendix to the report were the two treatment plans prepared by Dr. Luela Louis, dated December 12, 2014.

 

The Personal Medical Profile, dated January 6, 2015, provided by the family doctor and forwarded to the Insurer as discussed above, appears not to have been forwarded to Dr. Tuff. It is in any event not referred to in his report.

 

Danzig and St. Paul Fire & Marine Arbitration, Motion, FSCO 4902

https://www5.fsco.gov.on.ca/AD/4902

Dr. Moddel

 

The Applicant takes much issue with the way Dr. Moddel’s Neurological Assessment findings were incorporated – or more accurately not incorporated – into the Insurer’s multidisciplinary assessment culminating into the Executive Summary, despite that Dr. Moddel was part of that multidisciplinary team. Dr. Moddel opines on page 5 of his report that the Applicant suffered a closed head injury, and that, “I find this woman has a significant dementia and is now quite incapacitated following a motor vehicle accident.” In answers to the specific referral questions, he is clear that the diagnosis is related to the accident, and according to my reading, appears to dispute that the Applicant’s condition – e.g. her cognitive decline – is an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. The Applicant focuses, in particular, on Dr. Moddel’s finding that:

 

From a neurological point of view, Ms. Danzig suffered a severe cognitive impairment secondary to the motor vehicle accident. Please refer to the executive summary for the whole person impairment rating. (Emphasis added)

Galloway and Echelon Arbitration, Final Decision, FSCO 4899

 https://www5.fsco.gov.on.ca/AD/4899

Dr. Derry testified that Mrs. Galloway’s assessment lasted one hour, and that during this hour, a series of five tests was administered in another room.  He personally would have spent about half an hour with her.  His own notes were typed directly into his computer.  When shown a report of Ms. Delise Roberts, in which the summary was identical to the words in his own report, he stated, “I read the documents that were of particular relevance.  They are not my words, they are hers.”    Also on cross-examination, it became apparent that Dr. Derry had not seen many of the documents of Mrs. Galloway’s file.  His own report listed 72 documents, while Dr. Waisman’s report listed 364 reviewed documents.  He did not have Dr. Morrison’s notes, although he did speak with her.  In that conversation, they did not discuss the details of Mrs. Galloway’s therapy –   “I asked her about the focus of treatment and she told me, talk about pain and how she is coping.  I didn’t ask for details; it was important to know she is getting the treatment to address [her problems].”  The tests administered at this assessment did not address PTSD.

 

Doctor hired by WSIB in U.S. legal battle over slashed medical benefits

A doctor commissioned to write a report on “fair compensation” for Ontario’s injured workers is embroiled in a legal battle alleging he “conspired” with a private auto insurance company to unfairly cut car accident victims’ medical benefits, the Star has learned.

https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2016/06/13/doctor-hired-by-wsib-in-us-legal-battle-over-slashed-medical-benefits.html

Understanding Trauma: How Stress and Trauma Cause Chronic Pain, Anxiety, Depression, & PTSD

Watch this video to find out how Trauma and Stress impact the brain to create chronic conditions, like: chronic pain, depression, anxiety, post traumatic stress, and fibromyalgia. You will understand how the brain / body connection works and why nothing you’ve tried has helped so far. If you or a loved one suffer from chronic health problems no matter what you’ve tried, then you can’t afford to miss this cutting edge information.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=byQBP7fq5vQ&app=desktop

Optional Benefits Are Now Less “Optional” Than Ever

If you didn’t know that your automobile insurance benefits were reduced on June 1st, you are not alone. A recent survey conducted by the Insurance Brokers Association of Ontario (“IBAO”) revealed that only 42% of consumers had heard about the changes and less than 20% could actually identify what those changes were. All Ontario drivers need to be familiar with these reductions to auto insurance coverage and need to know that optional benefits exist to restore coverage.

http://otlablog.com/optional-benefits-less-optional/

Valerie Hurley, who lost her partner and newborn son in a crash one year ago, is turning her grief into help for others as Ontario reduces insurance benefits for crash victims

Valerie Hurley’s face lights up, remembering the day she and her boyfriend took their infant son to Clovermead Adventure Park.

It was a perfect late-summer outing for Hurley and her partner, John Tremblett, who snapped photos of baby Carstyn playing in the sand and sitting atop a porcelain horse.

http://www.lfpress.com/2016/06/05/valerie-hurley-who-lost-her-partner-and-newborn-son-in-a-crash-one-year-ago-is-turning-her-grief-into-help-for-others-as-ontario-reduces-insurance-benefits-for-crash-victims